A rare find in the City of Barrie! This private, treed 1.23-acre lot backs onto Lover's Creek in the exclusive lakeside South Shore neighbourhood. Steeped in history, the home was originally built in 1860, relocated & thoughtfully restored in 1988, preserving its character while modernizing key structural components, including plumbing, HVAC, electrical & foundation. Extensive renovations continued over the years, seamlessly blending heritage charm with modern comfort. Enjoy exceptional outdoor lifestyle with the Marina & walking trails steps away, beaches along Kempenfelt Bay within easy walking distance. Barrie's downtown & GO Train station close by.Inside, the impressive front foyer showcases the craftsmanship of the original staircase, hardwood floors & 16" baseboards. The spacious family/dining area features double French doors to the rear yard, a convenient side entrance & powder room. The renovated kitchen offers custom cabinetry, stone counters, top-of-the-line built-in appliances, a large island & walk-in pantry. Open to the adjoining living spaces, it is ideal for everyday living & entertaining. The expansive living room features a gas fireplace & oversized windows overlooking peaceful forest views.Upstairs, the primary suite offers its own fireplace, walk-in closet & 5-piece semi-ensuite with new double vanity, vintage freestanding tub & large walk-in shower. The guest suite, formerly the original staff quarters, includes a private bedroom, 3-piece bath, bonus space, laundry & its own staircase to the main level.The finished basement adds a rec room, large utility/laundry room a workshop with bulkhead access to the yard. Outside, the fenced backyard offers a cottage-like setting with an expansive covered composite deck-perfect for morning coffee or summer BBQs. A long laneway leads to the oversized double garage with loft space. Additional features include a built-in deck heater, BBQ gas hookup, irrigation system & a new roof installed this year.
About this home
Photos of 311 Tollendal Mill Road
Facts and features of 311 Tollendal Mill Road
| Type | Detached |
|---|---|
| Style | 2-Storey |
| Bedrooms | 5 |
| Bathrooms | 3 |
| Size | 3000-3500 sq ft |
| Lot | 351.02 x 221.58 Feet |
| Parking | 12 |
| Garage | Detached |
| Heating | Forced Air |
| Cooling | Central Air |
| Basement | Partially Finished, Separate Entrance |
| Exterior | Board & Batten , Wood |
| Age | 31-50 |
| Taxes | $10,890 (2026) |
| Days on market | 50 |
| Listing brokerage | ROYAL LEPAGE FIRST CONTACT REALTY |
Rooms
15 rooms, with sizes
| Room | Level | Size | Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Bedroom | Second | 20′ 8″ × 14′ 8″ 6.3 × 4.47 m | hardwood floor, gas fireplace, semi ensuite |
| Recreation | Basement | 30′ 0″ × 19′ 11″ 9.14 × 6.07 m | laminate, window |
| Foyer | Main | 17′ 1″ × 9′ 7″ 5.21 × 2.92 m | hardwood floor, staircase, large window |
| Bedroom 2 | Second | 15′ 4″ × 9′ 8″ 4.67 × 2.95 m | hardwood floor, walk-in closet(s), large window |
| Study | Second | 20′ 3″ × 7′ 5″ 6.17 × 2.26 m | Hardwood Floor |
| Workshop | Basement | 19′ 11″ × 12′ 5″ 6.07 × 3.78 m | unfinished, walk-up, w/o to yard |
| Bedroom 4 | Main | 12′ 1″ × 10′ 3″ 3.68 × 3.12 m | hardwood floor, large window |
| Kitchen | Main | 19′ 8″ × 14′ 1″ 5.99 × 4.29 m | hardwood floor, stone counters, pantry |
| Bedroom 5 | Main | 12′ 1″ × 10′ 0″ 3.68 × 3.05 m | hardwood floor, large window |
| Utility Room | Basement | 35′ 3″ × 13′ 1″ 10.74 × 3.99 m | combined w/laundry, laundry sink, unfinished |
| Living Room | Main | 21′ 0″ × 20′ 6″ 6.4 × 6.25 m | hardwood floor, gas fireplace, large window |
| Family Room | Main | 21′ 7″ × 14′ 1″ 6.58 × 4.29 m | hardwood floor, open concept, w/o to porch |
| Laundry | Second | 8′ 7″ × 6′ 6″ 2.62 × 1.97 m | |
| Dining Room | Main | 14′ 1″ × 13′ 5″ 4.29 × 4.09 m | hardwood floor, open concept, w/o to porch |
| Bedroom 3 | Second | 15′ 0″ × 14′ 4″ 4.57 × 4.37 m | hardwood floor, walk-in closet(s) |
Request a showing
311 Tollendal Mill Road
Nearby, at a similar price
See more homes like this one
$1,250,000 69 days on market MLS® S13696070
88 Cook Street
Detached · Barrie, ON · Codrington
Codrington
5 beds · 3 baths · 9 parking · 3000-3500 sq ft
3000-3500 sq ft
$1,300,000 56 days on market MLS® S13737850
19 Centre Street
Detached · Barrie, ON · Allandale
Allandale
5 beds · 4 baths · 12 parking · 2500-3000 sq ft
2500-3000 sq ft
$1,999,900 Listed today MLS® N14124940
1836 Quantz Crescent
Detached · Innisfil, ON · Rural Innisfil
Rural Innisfil
5 beds · 5 baths · 22 parking · 3000-3500 sq ft
3000-3500 sq ft
$1,200,000 64 days on market MLS® S13710848
31 The Queensway
Detached · Barrie, ON · Innis-Shore
Innis-Shore
5+1 beds · 5 baths · 4 parking · 3000-3500 sq ft
3000-3500 sq ft
$1,199,900 115 days on market MLS® S13524710
22 Ludlow Drive E
Detached · Barrie, ON · Rural Barrie Southeast
Rural Barrie Southeast
5 beds · 4 baths · 6 parking · 2500-3000 sq ft
2500-3000 sq ft
$1,550,000 269 days on market MLS® S12746916
69 CITYVIEW Circle
Detached · Barrie, ON · Holly
Holly
5 beds · 5 baths · 6 parking · 3000-3500 sq ft
3000-3500 sq ft
Ask a question
311 Tollendal Mill Road
Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by PropTx or the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board. Data source: PropTx. Listings are refreshed from the MLS® at least daily.
The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose.
Royal LePage Terrequity Seymour Real Estate, Brokerage. Independently owned and operated.
MLS® S13765708 Data source: PropTx Listed September 10, 2026